Treachery or transparency? Lifting of Wada ban on Russia’s doping agency divides sports world

The World Anti-Doping Agency on Thursday lifted a ban on Russia’s anti-doping agency, paving the way for Russian athletes to return to competition but also sparking claims of “treachery” and “dark shadows” cast over the fight against drugs in sport.

“Today, the great majority of Wada’s Executive Committee decided to reinstate Rusada as compliant with the World Anti-Doping Code subject to strict conditions,” Wada president Craig Reedie said.

Reedie said the decision “provides a clear timeline by which Wada must be given access to the former Moscow laboratory data and samples”.

He said if the commitment was not met, Wada would reinstate the ban on the Russian anti-doping agency.

The decision was taken at a meeting of Wada’s Executive Committee in Victoria, capital of the Indian Ocean island of Seychelles.

The Russian government applauded the decision to lift Rusada’s three-year suspension, saying it was the result of “enormous work” by Russian authorities to improve their procedures.

“We welcome Wada’s decision,” Deputy Prime Minister Olga Golodets was quoted by Russian news agencies as saying.

“Russia confirms its adherence to the principles of clean sports competition,” she said.

“Over the past years Russia has done enormous work to create transparent and understandable measures to prevent doping,” she said.

She said those measures included criminal prosecution for those who force someone to take banned substances.

‘Devastating blow’

However, condemnation of the decision was swift and brutal.

Linda Helleland, vice-president of Wada, said the decision to lift the ban “casts a dark shadow over the credibility of the anti-doping movement”.

“I am disappointed on behalf of clean athletes and everyone who believes in clean sport,” wrote Helleland, a Norwegian, who was one of only two Wada Executive Committee members to vote against.

“Today we made the wrong decision in protecting the integrity of sport and to maintain public trust. Today we failed clean athletes of the world.”

The US anti-doping body Usada called the decision to reinstate the Russian anti-doping body “a devastating blow to the world’s clean athletes”.

“In its landmark meeting today, Wada sent one clear message to the world: we put the wishes of a small handful of sports administrators above the rights of millions of clean athletes and the dreams of billions of sports fans,” Usada CEO Travis T Tygart said in a statement.

Wada suspended Rusada in November 2015 after declaring it to be non-compliant following revelations of a vast Russian-backed scheme to avoid drug testers.

A Wada report by Canadian lawyer Richard McLaren accused Russian authorities of running an elaborate doping programme with the full support of the Russian Ministry of Sport and the Russian secret service (FSB).

Wada announced last week it had received an internal recommendation to lift the suspension of Rusada.

The softening of Wada’s stance has triggered outrage from athletes and national anti-doping agencies around the world, who have accused Wada of caving in to pressure from the International Olympic Committee (IOC).

Leading athletes signed a joint letter this week against the plan to reinstate Russia saying WADA “owe it to all clean athletes to be the guardians of clean sport”.

Jim Walden, the lawyer of Russian doping whistleblower Grigory Rodchenkov, led the first wave of outcries at Thursday’s decision.

“Wada’s decision to reinstate Russia represents the greatest treachery against clean athletes in Olympic history,” said Walden, whose client lifted the lid on Russia’s doping scandal in 2015.

Two more pre-conditions

Rusada’s reinstatement could have far-reaching implications across the sports world.

Most significantly, it removes a key obstacle to lifting the suspension of Russia by the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF), track and field’s global governing body.

The IAAF has taken a hardline stance on Russian athletes since the scandal emerged, refusing to lift its ban shortly before the European Championships.

The IAAF will review Russia’s status once more at its council meeting in Monaco in December after a report into two more pre-conditions on which they have insisted – an acknowledgement by the Russian authorities that there was a cover-up and access to test samples data from the Moscow lab between 2011 and 2015.

“The setting of our own criteria and the process of evaluating progress against these criteria has served athletics well over the last three years so we will continue to rely on the taskforce and our clear roadmap for RusAF (Russian athletics federation) reinstatement until we are satisfied that the conditions have been met,” said IAAF chief Sebastian Coe.

Meanwhile, the IOC said it had taken note of the Wada decision.