As Diwali approaches and Hindus prepare to celebrate the triumphant return of Lord Ram to his Kingdom (and the spanking new temple that is being built for him in Ayodhya), the rest of us must be content to celebrate this season of serial triumphs for Indian Democracy. Between the breaking news of a disturbing cremation, the laying to rest of one great conspiracy and the inauguration of another, how can we not be proud of ourselves, our cultural and civilisational values, both ancient and modern?
In mid-September, reports came in of a 19-year old Dalit girl who was gang-raped, mutilated and left for dead by dominant caste men in her village in Hathras, Uttar Pradesh. Her family was one of 15 Dalit families in a village where a majority of the 600 households were Brahmin and Thakur – the same caste as Ajay Singh Bisht, the saffron-robed Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister who calls himself Yogi Adityanath. (He is, by all accounts, being groomed to replace Narendra Modi as Prime Minister in the near future.)
The girl had been stalked and terrorised by her assailants for a while. She had nobody to turn to for help. Nobody to protect her. So, she stayed at home and rarely went out. She and her family were aware of what was in store for them. But awareness didn’t help. Her mother found her daughter’s bleeding body in the field where she took her cows to graze. Her tongue had been almost severed, her spine broken, leaving her paralysed.
The girl survived for two weeks, first in a hospital in Aligarh and then, as her condition worsened, in a hospital in Delhi. On the night of September 29, she died. The Uttar Pradesh police, best known for pulling off 400 custodial killings last year – almost a fourth of the all-India total of nearly 1,700 – whisked the girl’s body away in the dead of night and drove all the way back to the outskirts of her village. They locked up the traumatised family, denying the girl’s mother a final farewell, a chance to gaze upon her daughter’s face, and denying the community the dignity of performing the last rites for a beloved who has departed this world. Denying them even the definite knowledge that it was indeed their daughter’s body that was cremated.
The murdered girl’s broken body was laid on a hurriedly put together pyre, and the smoke rose into the night sky from behind a wall of khaki police uniforms. The girl’s family huddled together, clearly terrified by the blaze of media attention. Terrified because they knew very well that when the lights faded, they would be punished for that attention, too.
If they manage to survive, they will go back to the lives they have grown used to – victims of medieval cruelty and indignity meted out to them in their medieval caste-ridden village where they are considered untouchable and sub-human.
A day after the cremation, confident that the body had been safely dispatched, the police have announced that the girl had not been raped. She had only been murdered. Only. This marks the beginning of the standard operating procedure in which the caste angle is quickly excised from caste atrocities. Courts, hospital records and the mainstream media can all be expected to cooperate in this process of gradually turning a hate-fueled caste atrocity into just another unfortunate but ordinary crime.
In other words, absolving our society, letting our culture and social practices off the hook. We have seen it time and time again, most graphically in the 2006 massacre and brutalisation of Surekha Bhotmange and her two children in Khairlanji.
As part of our effort to return our country to her glorious past as the Bharatiya Janata Party promises it will do, in the next election, if you can, please don’t forget to vote for Ajay Singh Bisht. If not him, then for the nearest Muslim-baiting, Dalit-hating politician, whoever he or she may be. Remember to “like” the next lynching video that’s uploaded, and to keep watching your favourite, venom-spewing TV anchor, because he or she is the Keeper of our collective conscience.
Also, please don’t forget to be grateful that we can still vote, that we live in the world’s largest democracy and that unlike what we like to call the “failed states” in our neighborhood, in India we have neutral courts that administer the Rule of Law.
Only a few hours after that shameful, horrifying cremation outside the village in Hathras, on the morning of September 30, a Central Bureau of Investigation special court gave us a robust demonstration of just such neutrality and probity.
After 28 years of careful deliberation it acquitted all the 32 people who had been accused of conspiring to demolish the Babri Masjid in 1992, an event that changed the course of the history of Modern India. The acquitted included a former Home Minister, a former Cabinet Minister and a former Chief Minister. In effect, it appears that nobody demolished the Babri Masjid. At least not legally. Perhaps the mosque demolished itself. Perhaps all those years ago, it picked that day, December 6, Babasaheb Ambedkar’s death anniversary, to hammer itself into dust, to crumble under the collective willpower of the saffron-scarfed thugs who called themselves devotees that had gathered there that day.
It turns out that the videos and photographs we all saw of the men hammering down the old mosque’s domes, the witness testimonies that we read and heard, the news reports that filled the media in the months that followed were figments of our imagination. LK Advani’s Rath Yatra, when he travelled the length and breadth of India in an open truck, addressing huge crowds, shutting down city roads, exhorting true Hindus to converge on Ayodhya and participate in building a Ram temple at the exact spot where the mosque stood – all of that never really happened.
Neither did the death and destruction that his Yatra left in its wake. Nobody chanted Ek dhakka aur do, Babri Masjid tod do. We were experiencing a collective, nation-wide hallucination. What were we all smoking? Why aren’t we being summoned by the Narcotics Control Bureau? Why are only Bollywood folks being summoned? Are we not all equal in the eyes of the law?
The Special Court judge has written a detailed 2,300-page judgement about how there was no plan to destroy the mosque. That’s a feat, you have to admit – 2,300 pages about the absence of a plan. He describes how there is absolutely no evidence to say that the accused had met “in a room” to plan the demolition. Perhaps that’s because it happened outside a room, on our streets, at public meetings, on our TV screens for all of us to watch and participate in? Or heck – is it just that “maal” again, giving us these ideas?
Anyway, the Babri Masjid conspiracy is out for now. But there’s another one that’s “in” and “trending”. The conspiracy of the 2020 Delhi massacre in which 53 people (40 of them Muslim) were killed and 581 injured in the working-class neighborhoods of North East Delhi. Mosques, graveyards and madrassas were specifically targeted. Homes, shops and businesses, for the most part Muslim, were firebombed and razed to the ground.
In the case of this conspiracy, the Delhi Police chargesheet which runs into thousands of pages, even has a photograph of a few people sitting around a table – Yes! in a room, a sort of office basement – plotting. You can clearly tell by their expressions that they’re plotting. What’s more, there are accusing arrows pointing at them, identifying them, telling us their names. It’s devastating.
Far more alarming than those men with sledge-hammers on the dome of the Babri Masjid. Some of the people sitting around the table are already in jail. The rest probably soon will be. The arrests took just a few months. The acquittals could take years – if the Babri judgement is anything to go by, then maybe 28 years, who knows.
Under the UAPA (Unlawful Activities [Prevention] Act), with which they have been charged, almost everything is a crime including thinking anti-national thoughts. The onus is on you to prove your innocence. The more I read about it and the modus operandi the police adopt around it, the more it sounds like asking a sane person to establish her sanity before a committee of lunatics.
The Delhi conspiracy, we are asked to believe, was hatched by Muslim students and activists, Gandhians, “Urban Naxals” and “Leftists” who were all protesting against the implementation of the National Population Register, the National Register of Citizenship and the Citizenship Amendment Act, which they believed combine together to cut the very ground from under the feet of the Muslim community and India’s poor who do not have “legacy papers”. I believe that, too. And I believe that if the government decides to push ahead with that project, the protests will start again. As they should.
According to the police, the idea behind the Delhi conspiracy was to embarrass the Indian government by inciting violence and creating a bloody, communal conflagration during US President Donald Trump’s state visit to India in February. The non-Muslims who are named in the chargesheet are accused of conspiring to give the protests a “secular color”. The thousands of Muslim women who were leading the sit-ins and protests are accused of being “brought in” to give the protests “gender cover”.
All the flag-waving and public readings of the preamble to the Indian Constitution, and the outpouring of poetry and music and love that marked these protests, are dismissed as some sort of insincere fakery designed to disguise malign intent. In other words, the core of the protest is jihadi (and male) – the rest is just garnishing and decoration.
The young scholar, Dr Umar Khalid, who I know well, and who has been persecuted, hounded and fake-newsed by the media for years, is, according to the police, one of the chief conspirators. The evidence they have collected against him the police say, runs into more than one million pages. (This is the same government that declared it had no data on the 10 million workers who had to walk hundreds – and some thousands – of kilometres home to their villages in March after Modi announced the world’s most cruel Covid-19 lockdown – no idea of how many died, how many starved, how many fell sick.)
Not included in the one million pages of evidence against Umar Khalid is the CCTV footage of the Jafrabad Metro station – the site of his supposedly egregious plotting and provocation – which activists appealed to the Delhi High Court to preserve, as early as on February 25, even as the violence was raging. It has been inexplicably erased.
Umar Khalid is now in jail along with hundreds of other Muslims who have been recently arrested, charged under the UAPA as well as with murder, attempt to murder and rioting. How many lifetimes will it take for courts and lawyers to wade through one million pages of “evidence”?
Similar to the way in which the Babri Masjid appears to have decided to demolish itself, in the police version of the 2020 Delhi massacre, Muslims conspired to murder themselves, burn their own mosques, destroy their own homes, orphan their own children, all in order to show Donald Trump what a terrible time they’re having in India.
To bolster their case, the police have annexed to their chargesheet, hundreds of pages of WhatsApp conversations between students and activists and activist support groups that are trying to support and coordinate between the scores of sites of protests and peaceful sit-ins that had sprung up in Delhi. It could not be more different from another set of WhatsApp conversations by a group of people who call themselves Kattar Hindu Ekta or Hardline Hindu Unity, in which they actually boast about killing Muslims and openly praise Bharatiya Janata Party leaders. That is part of a separate chargesheet.
The student-activist conversations are, for the most part, full of spirit and purpose as young people, buoyed by a sense of righteous anger, go about their business. Reading them is energising and returns you to those heady pre-Covid days and the excitement of watching a new generation come into its own. Time and again, more experienced activists intervene to caution them about the need to stay peaceful and calm. They also argue and bicker in petty ways as activists tend to – that’s part of the business of being democratic.
The main bone of contention in the conversations, unsurprisingly, is whether or not to try and replicate the stunning success of the protest by the thousands of women of Shaheen Bagh who had, for weeks together, braving the bitter winter cold, squatted on a main road, blocking traffic, creating chaos, but drawing a huge amount of attention to themselves and their cause.
Bilkis Bano, the Dadi (Granny) of Shaheen Bagh, has made it to Time magazine’s most influential people of 2020. (Don’t confuse her with the other Bilkis Bano, the 19-year-old who survived 2002 anti-Muslim pogrom in Gujarat when Narendra Modi was chief minister of that state. She witnessed a massacre in which 14 members of her family including her three-year-old daughter were killed by a rampaging mob of Hindu vigilantes. She was pregnant and gang-raped. Only.)
The Delhi activists’ WhatsApp chatter has people divided over whether to go for a “chakka jam” – a road block – in North East Delhi or not. There’s nothing new about planning a chakka jam – farmers have done it time and again. They are doing it right now, in Punjab and Haryana, to protest the recently passed farm bills that corporatise Indian agriculture threaten to deliver small farmers into an existential crisis.
In the case of the Delhi protests, some activists on the chat groups argued that blocking roads would be counterproductive. Given the climate of open threats by BJP leaders in the area that was fueled by their rage at having been humiliated in the Delhi elections just weeks ago, some local activists feared that blocking roads would incite anger and direct the ensuing violence towards their communities. They knew that farmers or Gujjars or even Dalits doing it is one thing. Muslims doing it is quite another. That’s the reality in India today.
Others argued that unless roads were blocked and the city was forced to pay attention, the protestors would just be sidelined and ignored. As it turned out, in some protest sites, roads were blocked. As predicted, it gave Hindu vigilante mobs armed with weapons and murderous chants the opportunity they were looking for.
Over the next few days they unleashed a kind of brutality that took our breath away. Videos showed them being openly backed and supported by the police. Muslims fought back. Lives and property were lost on both sides. But entirely unequally. No equivalence can be made here. The violence was allowed to swell and spread. We watched in disbelief the spectacle of grievously injured young Muslim men lying on a road surrounded by police who forced them to sing the National Anthem. One of them, Faizan, died soon after.
Hundreds of distress calls were ignored by the police. When the arson and slaughter cooled down, and the hundreds of complaints were finally entertained, victims claimed that the police forced them to remove the names and identities of their attackers and the communal slogans raised by the gun- and sword-wielding mobs. Specific complaints were turned into generic ones designed to be inconclusive and protect the guilty. (Hate was excised from hate-crimes.)
On one of the WhatsApp chats, one particular Muslim activist who lived in North East Delhi and had repeatedly warned the others about the perils of a chakka jam, exited the group after posting a final bitter, recriminatory message. It is this message the police and the media have seized and built upon to spin their sordid web and tar the whole group –
among them India’s most respected activists, teachers and filmmakers – as a set of violent conspirators with murderous intent. Can there be anything more ridiculous?
But it could take years for innocence to be established. Until then they could be in jail, their lives completely ruined while the real murderers and provocateurs roam free and win elections. The process is intended to be the punishment.
Meanwhile several independent media reports, citizens’ fact-finding reports and human rights organisations have held the Delhi police complicit in the violence that took place in North East Delhi. In an August 2020 report, after having had some of the disturbingly violent videos that we all saw, forensically examined, Amnesty International said that the Delhi police are guilty of beating and torturing protestors and acting with the mob. Since then Amnesty has been accused of financial irregularities and its bank accounts have been frozen. It has had to close its India offices and let go of all 150 of its staff in India.
When things begin to get dire, the first to leave or be forced to leave, are international observers. In which countries have we seen this pattern before? Think. Or Google.
India wants a permanent place on the United Nations Security Council, a say in world affairs. But it also wants to be one of the five countries in the world that will not ratify the international covenant against torture. It wants to be a one-party democracy (an oxymoron) with zero accountability.
The real purpose of the absurd police-manufactured 2020 Delhi conspiracy, and equally absurd 2018 Bhima-Koregaon conspiracy (the absurdity is part of the threat and the humiliation) is to imprison and pin down activists, students, lawyers, writers, poets, professors, trade-unionists and noncompliant NGOs. It has to do not just with erasing the horrors of the past and present, but also with clearing the decks for what is still to come.
I suppose we ought to be grateful for these one-million page evidence gatherings and 2,000-page court judgements. Because they are proof that the carcass of democracy is still being dragged around. It hasn’t been cremated yet, unlike the murdered girl in Hathras, Uttar Pradesh. Even as a carcass, it’s pulling its weight, slowing things down. The day is not far off when it will be jettisoned and things will speed up. The unspoken slogan amongst those who rule us may well be Ek dhakka aur do, Democracy gaad do. Bury it.
When that day comes, 1,700 custodial killings in a year will seem like a rosy recollection of our recent, glorious past.
Let that small fact not deter us. Let’s keep voting for the people who are leading us into penury and war, tearing us apart limb from limb.
At least they are building us a grand temple. And that’s not nothing.
Limited-time offer: Big stories, small price. Keep independent media alive. Become a Scroll member today!
Our journalism is for everyone. But you can get special privileges by buying an annual Scroll Membership. Sign up today!