The Big Story: Temple and State

The Bharatiya Janata Party president Amit Shah outraged a section of Malayalis on Tuesday with a seemingly innocuous festival greeting. Wishing people for “Vaman Jayanti”, Shah put out a Hindi-language poster on Facebook and Twitter that shows a Brahmin dwarf placing his foot on the head of the legendary king of Kerala, Mahabali. Mahabali is saluting the Brahmin in a gesture of submission.

Onam is Kerala’s biggest festival. The mythological story underpinning the celebration revolves around the Malayali king Mahabali, whose rule is considered a golden period. However, his power made the Devas, Vedic gods, envious which led to Vishnu taking the form of a Brahmin dwarf and tricking Mahabali into defeat. Mahabali was sent to hell but he still returns annually to visit Kerala – which is when his former kingdom celebrates Onam.

Advertisement

Shah’s poster, therefore, attempts at drastic rewiring of the Onam legend: now the dwarf Brahmin is seen to be the hero, not Mahabali. In fact, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh has been pushing this story for some time now in Kerala as part of its efforts to introduce Hindutva into the state.

Not unexpectedly, Shah’s depiction angered Malayalis. Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan demanded an apology from the BJP chief and #PoMoneShahji (get lost, Sonny) trended on social media.

However, this issue goes much beyond just Kerala or Onam. What is truly outrageous about this is the naked use of religion to push a political agenda. Whether Malayalis want to worship Vaman or Mahabali is up to them. It is not for the BJP president to act as a religious leader and push theology.

Advertisement

The firm intertwining of faith and religion is nothing new in India. Way back in 1895, Congress leader Bal Gangadhar Tilak had used a religious festival, Ganesh Chauturthi, as a means to mobilise Marathis politically. Later, on the national stage, Gandhi would combine Hindu iconography as well as Muslim elements such as the Khilafat to try and conduct a new style of mass politics. In 1946, the Muslim League would directly go to Muslim Punjabis and claim that not voting for the League would result in them losing their religion.

While each use of religion yielded short-term political gains, the long-term effect on the subcontinent was disastrous. In fact, the BJP’s rise in the 1980s and 1990s was due to the Ayodhya temple movement ­– hardly a desirous template for a country entering a new millennium.

Unfortunately, it seems the electoral dividends from the use of religion means that it is not going to end soon. It is up to Indians of all stripes and classes to demand that politicians stop using theology to win their votes and concentrate on the more secular matter of human development.

The Big Scroll

Was Mahabali sent to hell? A debate simmers in Kerala over Onam’s origin myth

Political Picks

  1. The United Nations has sought “unconditional access” to Kashmir citing reports of excessive use of force by India.
  2. For the first time in the Valley, the Jammu and Kashmir government, which clamped curfew across Kashmir on Tuesday to pre-empt trouble on the streets, barred people from offering Eid prayers at major Sufi shrines, mosques and Idgahs.
  3. Karnataka accepts Supreme Court order on Cauvery water sharing. Two people have died in protests, as Tamil-Kannadiga tensions simmer.
  4. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav strips his uncle Shivpal Yadav of key ministerial berths.
  5. Why Rahul Gandhi’s yatra is leaving the Uttar Pradesh voter, and Congress worker, more confused.

Punditry

  1. India and Pakistan’s intransigence in expanding trade has hurt the people of both countries, says Suhasini Haidar in The Hindu.
  2. There has to be greater honesty in Union-state relations to make cooperative federalism work, says SL Rao in The Telegraph.
  3. Indians are rioting over water. Is this a glimpse into the future, asks Annie Gowen in the Washington Post.

Giggle

Don’t Miss

Advertisement

M Rajshekhar explains how Karnataka and Tamil Nadu mismanaged their water and then blamed each other.

Evidence of this can be found across the state. Travelling along the Noyyal, a small river that flows past Coimbatore and Tirupur before merging into the Cauvery, this reporter came across instances where groundwater levels were as low as 1,000 feet. Ten years ago, villagers said, they used to find water at 600 feet. And 20 years ago, they just had to dig 200 feet.

This is the story in large parts of the state. According to Tamil Nadu’s Water Supply and Drainage Board, as many as 142 of the state’s 385 blocks are over-exploited – they are drawing out more water than is replenished in the year. Another 90 are moving in the same direction – classified as “critical” (33) or “semi-critical” (57).

Liked what you read? Subscribe to "The Daily Fix" everyday by either downloading Scroll's Android app or opting for it to be delivered to your mailbox.