On Tuesday, author and columnist Shobhaa De put out a series of tweets criticising Maharashtra government's decision to make it mandatory for multiplexes to screen at least one Marathi film between 6 pm-9 pm every day.
Shiv Sena MLA Pratap Sarnaik did not like De's tweets. While he has a twitter account himself, he chose not to use it to air disagreement with her views. Instead, he took his objections to the state assembly where he moved a privilege motion against her.
A privilege motion allows a member of a legislative house to call attention to any statement made in public, either in the form of a speech or published and aired in the media, that casts 'reflections’ on the house and its members, which may impede them from discharging their functions.
So what did Shobhaa De say in her tweets that could affect the functioning of the Maharashtra assembly?
According to media reports, Sarnaik, elected from Mira-Bhayander on the outskirts of Mumbai, took the view that De's tweets amounted to an insult to Maharashtra. He claimed the author had hurt the sentiments of the house which had supported culture minister Vinod Tawde’s decision to screen Marathi films in all multiplexes each evening.
Shobhaa De quickly shot back with a tweet as soon as the news of the privilege motion came in.
This is not the first time that Shobhaa De and Shiv Sena have found each other at loggerheads over tweets. In the wake of Telangana’s formation, De had tweeted in 2013 that 'Mumbai has always fancied itself as an independent entity’ which drew ire from both the Shiv Sena and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena.
Even as MNS chief Raj Thackeray made personal remarks against her, Shiv Sena spokesperson Sanjay Rout demanded a police case against her and even the BJP’s Mumbai unit president Ashish Shelar told the legislative council to take action against De’s tweet.
But a privilege motion could be more serious business. If passed, the Assembly could ask the accused to appear before the assembly. The accusedhasd could be let off with a warning or sent to prison. Until 7 pm on Wednesday evening, Sarnaik's motion had not been admitted.
When contacted, Shobhaa De declined comment. Sarnaik did not take phone calls.
On Twitter, many took De's side for speaking her mind.
Shiv Sena MLA Pratap Sarnaik did not like De's tweets. While he has a twitter account himself, he chose not to use it to air disagreement with her views. Instead, he took his objections to the state assembly where he moved a privilege motion against her.
A privilege motion allows a member of a legislative house to call attention to any statement made in public, either in the form of a speech or published and aired in the media, that casts 'reflections’ on the house and its members, which may impede them from discharging their functions.
So what did Shobhaa De say in her tweets that could affect the functioning of the Maharashtra assembly?
Devendra 'Diktatwala' Fadnavis is at it again!!!From beef to movies. This is not the Maharashtra we all love! Nako!Nako! Yeh sab roko!
— Shobhaa De (@DeShobhaa) April 7, 2015
I love Marathi movies. Let me decide when and where to watch them, Devendra Fadnavis. This is nothing but Dadagiri.
— Shobhaa De (@DeShobhaa) April 7, 2015
No more pop corn at multiplexes in Mumbai? Dahi misal and vada pav only. To go better with the Marathi movies at prime time .
— Shobhaa De (@DeShobhaa) April 7, 2015
According to media reports, Sarnaik, elected from Mira-Bhayander on the outskirts of Mumbai, took the view that De's tweets amounted to an insult to Maharashtra. He claimed the author had hurt the sentiments of the house which had supported culture minister Vinod Tawde’s decision to screen Marathi films in all multiplexes each evening.
Apologise for insulting Maharashtra: Shiv Sena to Shobhaa De
— IANS Tweets (@ians_india) April 8, 2015
Shobhaa De quickly shot back with a tweet as soon as the news of the privilege motion came in.
Now a privilege motion demanding an apology from me? Come on! I am a proud Maharashtrian and love Marathi films. Always have. Always will !
— Shobhaa De (@DeShobhaa) April 8, 2015
This is not the first time that Shobhaa De and Shiv Sena have found each other at loggerheads over tweets. In the wake of Telangana’s formation, De had tweeted in 2013 that 'Mumbai has always fancied itself as an independent entity’ which drew ire from both the Shiv Sena and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena.
Even as MNS chief Raj Thackeray made personal remarks against her, Shiv Sena spokesperson Sanjay Rout demanded a police case against her and even the BJP’s Mumbai unit president Ashish Shelar told the legislative council to take action against De’s tweet.
But a privilege motion could be more serious business. If passed, the Assembly could ask the accused to appear before the assembly. The accusedhasd could be let off with a warning or sent to prison. Until 7 pm on Wednesday evening, Sarnaik's motion had not been admitted.
When contacted, Shobhaa De declined comment. Sarnaik did not take phone calls.
On Twitter, many took De's side for speaking her mind.
Privilege motion against @DeShobhaa is a joke. She has every right to criticize govt decision to block prime slot for Marathi films.
— nikhil wagle (@waglenikhil) April 8, 2015
@DeShobhaa Congrats on earning ire of the Maharashtra govt. You must have done something right ;)
— Dave Swami (@Deviouswami) April 8, 2015
Add another Indian author to the list of people the govt. would love to silence. This time, Shobhaa De. http://t.co/oWzxsHfHkG
— Sonia Faleiro (@soniafaleiro) April 8, 2015
@Dev_Fadnavis Do u also want to ban free speech? @DeShobhaa has every right to voice opinion. Prvlg motion? Comeon!! https://t.co/B0v03M3Qts
— Rupali Mehra (@rupalimehra) April 8, 2015
Whatever @DeShobhaa said I fully subscribe to. Please move a #PrivilegeMotion against me too! #MaharashtraAssembly. #FreeSpeech
— Amit A. Pai (@amitpai87) April 8, 2015
@DeShobhaa #5staractivist is at it again with cheap publicity stunts !! #Shobhadey
— Kedar Kekan (@KedarKekan) April 8, 2015
Marathi has always had a weak lobby.Govt is doing its bit to make a change & it has to face jokes from @DeShobhaa? Sad.
— ashish shelar (@ShelarAshish) April 8, 2015
So a privilege motion against @DeShobhaa. Interesting. Wonder what's healthier- Her privilege to speak or their privilege to gag.
— Akil Bakhshi (@AB_Mystique) April 8, 2015
@DeShobhaa Vilifying Misal Paav is unforgivable. They shld now force you to eat one unless u apologise
— Clean_Chit (@Ihate_dishonest) April 8, 2015
@bombaywallah wait till irony is banned @BDUTT @DeShobhaa
— Isheta Salgaocar (@IshetaS) April 8, 2015
Limited-time offer: Big stories, small price. Keep independent media alive. Become a Scroll member today!
Our journalism is for everyone. But you can get special privileges by buying an annual Scroll Membership. Sign up today!